Bread Stuffing with Herbs

By Sally Cameron on November 13, 2011

holiday dishes, Side Dishes, thanksgiving, vegan, vegetarian,


Bread Stuffing with Herbs|

Bread Stuffing with Herbs

Stuffing or dressing? My mom and I used to go round and around about what its called. She called it stuffing because she cooked it stuffed inside the bird. For faster roasting and food safety reasons, I prefer to cook it separately in a shallow casserole, hence the term dressing.

No matter what you call it, you can’t serve a traditional Thanksgiving dinner without it. Here’s my recipe, a take on my mom’s traditional turkey stuffing or turkey dressing with herbs, fennel and leeks, my bread stuffing with herbs.

Family Tradition

One year it hit me that my mom would not live forever. If I wanted to make her traditional turkey stuffing I’d better pay attention. Notebook in hand, I followed her around the kitchen one Thanksgiving, documenting her every step. Because she never used a recipe, I made her measure everything she used.

With my mom now gone, I’m thankful for those memories and the lessons learned. With bread being the main component in stuffing, good quality bread is essential. Mom always used white bread, which I rarely buy. It’s been replaced by healthier whole wheat for sandwiches and breakfast toast. But for stuffing, you can’t beat classic white bread.

I did some research before choosing my bread. Visiting every grocery store in my area, reviewing the brands and reading the labels was eye opening. One popular brand had 4 grams of fat and 2 grams of saturated fat per slice. I eventually chose a healthy artisan-style loaf from an organic bakery with ingredients you could pronounce.

Dry Your Bread

Lay the bread slices out on a cutting board. Trim the crusts and discard the heels. I used to save them and feed the ducks at a local park. Next, trim the slices into small cubes about ½”-3/4” in size. Spread the cubes out on a rimmed baking sheet (or two for plenty of air circulation) and allow them to stand uncovered 18-24 hours to dry. You can do this several days ahead, packaging the dry cubes in an airtight container or plastic zip bag until you are ready to continue.

Prep Your Vegetables

Instead of just onion and celery, I add fennel, leeks and garlic for more flavor in the “aromatics” department. If you have not cooked with fennel or leeks, they add good texture, flavor and depth of flavor to the stuffing. For leeks – Trim the dark green top of off the leek and discard (or save for making stock or broth). Trim off the root end. Slice the light green and white part of the leek in half lengthwise and run under cold water to dislodge any sand or grit. Cut leek crosswise into thin strips.

For fennel – Trim stalks off the top of the fennel bulb. Save fluffy fronds for garnish if desired. Trim the bottom of the fennel bulb. Cut the bulb in half top to bottom, then slice into long strips. Cut the strips crosswise into a small dice.

Make the Stuffing

To make your stuffing, cook the vegetables (leek, fennel, celery and onion) with garlic slowly in your “fat” of choice. I use olive oil or an olive oil and butter combination for the flavor and richness. Mom used to use a whole cube of butter. Being health-minded, I can’t bring myself to do that, even though it tastes wonderful. Use a large saute pan or skillet over medium low heat and cook until the vegetables are soft and translucent. Bread Stuffing with Herbs| Next, add your bread cubes to the pan and stir together. Bread Stuffing with Herbs| Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the milk and herbs. You can also use chicken, turkey or vegetable broth, or almond milk for vegans as the liquid. If you’d like to make a slightly richer version, whisk a whole egg into the milk before combining with the bread and vegetable mixture.

Place stuffing in an oiled medium sized shallow casserole; 11″ x 7″ or 9″ x 9″ will work. Cover with foil and bake until golden. You may want to remove the foil the last few minutes for better browning. Serve with your turkey. This recipe is also great served with roast chicken throughout the year.

NOTE – Since posting this recipe we have gone both wheat and gluten-free. I have yet to experiment using GF bread. As soon as I do I will post notes for all of my GF buddies.

Helpful links on companion recipes, tools and information


Leave a Comment
Madonna | November 14, 2011 at 11:45 am

I don’t mean to gush, but I just love your site. Your dressing recipe is similar to my mom and dad’s, so I am going to try yours this year. I love the idea of the leek and fennel for more flavor.

Your photos are beautiful, and I like peaking at your kitchen tools/gadgets. Funny huh? Also I love that you are providing weight along with volume measure. I resisted the use of weight in the beginning, but my food consistently improved so now I have embraced it. Thanks for sharing.

Sergio | December 25, 2012 at 5:59 am

Hi! Thank you for sharing this recipe.
We prepared it for a Christmas dinner with our friends and everybody loved it. The leek and the fennel add a great taste.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *